When the Numbers No Longer Match: A Business Manager Case Study (Part 2)

SPECIAL INTERVIEW · PART 2 OF 3

When the Numbers No Longer Match: A Business Manager Case Study

A real-world example shows what happens when remuneration, social insurance, immigration plans, and business reality drift apart.

Three professionals discussing support for foreign entrepreneurs in Japan
← READ PART 1

In Part 2, the three professionals examine an anonymized consultation involving an underperforming accommodation business, unpaid director remuneration, social insurance, and an approaching visa renewal. The case reveals why repairing one number cannot repair an entire business structure.

01

Case study: when remuneration, social insurance, and visa renewal no longer matched

During the interview, the participants discussed a recent consultation in anonymized form. The client was a foreign business owner living in a regional area of Japan. He had purchased a property before launching a small accommodation business, but the business had not developed as planned and he had been unable to hire staff.
KAKUTax Accountant

When the company was established, the director's monthly remuneration was set at JPY 180,000, and the company enrolled him in social insurance on that basis. The company later ran short of funds and stopped paying the remuneration. He then told the pension office that his salary had been reduced to JPY 18,000, so the social insurance treatment was changed.

KAKUTax Accountant

He subsequently became concerned that such a low remuneration could damage his Business Manager renewal. He therefore asked whether the social insurance amount could remain based on JPY 180,000 even though the company was not actually paying him that amount.

HIROSELabor & Social Security Attorney

No. A company cannot preserve a social insurance grade that does not reflect the remuneration actually decided and paid. The pension office may ask for payroll ledgers, bank records, or other evidence of payment.

KAKUTax Accountant

Tax creates another problem. Directors' remuneration cannot be raised and lowered whenever convenient in the same way as ordinary employee pay. If the timing or procedure is wrong, part of the expense may not be deductible for corporate tax. We also need to ask how unpaid remuneration and withholding tax were recorded.

SHIMIZUImmigration Specialist

An extremely low remuneration also raises the question of how the manager can support himself in Japan. If the business is inactive, has not hired as planned, and has not produced the expected sales, the renewal issue is much broader than one number. Restoring the remuneration on paper does not repair the underlying business.

KAKUTax Accountant

If the founder had built one financial plan covering the immigration requirements, affordable remuneration, employer social insurance, and tax before forming the company, these contradictions would have been visible much earlier.

All three participants reached the same conclusion: immigration, remuneration, social insurance, and tax cannot be designed separately and reconciled later. Fixing one figure does not repair the whole structure.
02

Buying property does not give you the right to remain in Japan

KAKUTax Accountant

If the business fails and the owner cannot renew the status of residence, the property still exists. Does owning it provide any right to remain in Japan?

SHIMIZUImmigration Specialist

No. Property ownership and immigration status are entirely separate. Buying property in Japan does not create or preserve a status of residence. If Business Manager cannot be renewed, the person must consider whether another status is available. If not, the person must leave Japan. What happens to the company and property is a separate issue.

KAKUTax Accountant

The owner may need to sell or lease the property, or transfer the company or business to a third party. None of those choices eliminates the remaining contractual and tax responsibilities. Leaving Japan does not make the Japanese company disappear.

KAKUTax Accountant

A Japanese company may still have filing and payment obligations after its owner leaves. A nonresident who continues owning Japanese property may also need a tax representative. The exit plan should be considered before the purchase, not after the business has already failed.

03

A minpaku business is more than buying one property

KAKUTax Accountant

Private lodging and vacant-home projects are often presented to foreigners as an accessible way to live and do business in Japan. Some buyers are told that a particular property can be used for minpaku and will generate a profit, so they purchase the property first.

SHIMIZUImmigration Specialist

The question is whether one or two properties can cover the owner's remuneration, employee costs, maintenance, and other operating expenses and still produce an operating profit. Accommodation income alone may not be enough. A wider revenue model may be necessary.

KAKUTax Accountant

Before buying, the financial plan needs to include repairs, operating expenses, labor, social insurance, and tax—not just projected sales. The seller's explanation is not a substitute for testing whether the business works financially.

The participants discussed adding related experiences, cultural activities, or local services to the revenue model. However, each additional activity may bring new licensing, staffing, and operational requirements. The entire business needs to be designed as one system from the outset.
04

Turning the desire to live in Japan into a viable business

SHIMIZUImmigration Specialist

Many clients first visit Japan as tourists, fall in love with the culture, and decide they want to live here. Japan's anime, manga, food, and broader cultural appeal are extremely strong overseas. That enthusiasm is wonderful—but 'I want to live in Japan, so I need some kind of business' is not a business plan. The business has to make sense on its own.

HIROSELabor & Social Security Attorney

Japan's population is declining, and the country will increasingly need the contribution of foreign residents. Creating a place where foreign people can work and do business comfortably is good for Japan as well. That requires both compliance with the rules and fair treatment based on mutual understanding.

Continue the Conversation

The final part explores the role of culture, technology, and human judgment.

CONTINUE TO PART 3: PEOPLE, TECHNOLOGY & TRUST

Connect with the Three Professionals

Each professional handles a different part of building and operating a business in Japan. Visit the relevant office directly, or consult all three when the issues overlap.

KAKU

Japanese corporate and individual tax, consumption tax, accounting, filings, and tax-authority correspondence.

KAKU ASUMI TAX OFFICE →